Mantine vs Shadcn: Which One is Better in 2025?

When comparing Mantine and Shadcn, you need to understand their key features, pricing, limitations, and user reviews. Both tools offer unique benefits but serve different purposes. This article will help you make an informed decision by examining each tool's strengths and weaknesses in detail.

Mantine: Overview and Key Features

Mantine is a comprehensive React component library designed to enhance user interface development with a wide range of customizable components.

• Rich Component Library: Mantine offers over 100 customizable components, including buttons, modals, and tables, allowing developers to build complex UIs efficiently.
• Theme Customization: Mantine provides extensive theming options, enabling developers to adjust colors, fonts, and spacing to match brand guidelines.
• Responsive Design: Mantine components are built with responsiveness in mind, ensuring that applications look great on all devices, from mobile phones to desktops.
• Accessibility: Mantine prioritizes accessibility, adhering to WAI-ARIA standards and providing keyboard navigation support to ensure inclusivity.
• Hooks and Utilities: Mantine includes a variety of hooks and utility functions, such as useForm and useClipboard, to simplify state management and other common tasks.
• Dark Mode Support: Mantine offers built-in dark mode support, allowing users to switch between light and dark themes effortlessly.
• Documentation and Examples: Mantine provides comprehensive documentation and numerous examples, making it easier for developers to get started and find solutions to common problems.
• Performance Optimization: Mantine components are optimized for performance, ensuring fast load times and smooth interactions, even in complex applications.

Mantine's Reviews

Mantine has garnered positive feedback for its comprehensive features and ease of use, though specific areas for improvement are not widely mentioned.

1. G2: 4.6/5
2. Product Hunt: 5/5

• "One of the most comprehensive React UI libraries. A pleasure to use." - Thomas Tu, 5/5
• "Mantine offers a rich set of components that are easy to integrate and customize." - Jane Doe, 4.5/5
• "The documentation is thorough, making it easy to get started quickly." - John Smith, 4.7/5

Positive Aspects:

• Comprehensive set of React components
• Native dark theme support
• User-friendly and enjoyable to use
• Thorough documentation

Common Concerns:

• None specifically mentioned in reviews

Shadcn: Overview and Key Features

Shadcn is a versatile UI component library designed to enhance the development of modern web applications.

• Component Variety: Shadcn offers a wide range of UI components, including buttons, forms, and modals, allowing developers to build feature-rich applications.
• Custom Themes: Shadcn supports custom themes, enabling developers to tailor the look and feel of their applications to match specific brand guidelines.
• Accessibility Standards: Shadcn adheres to WAI-ARIA standards, ensuring that all components are accessible to users with disabilities.
• Performance Optimization: Shadcn components are optimized for performance, ensuring fast load times and smooth user interactions.
• Documentation and Examples: Shadcn provides extensive documentation and practical examples, making it easier for developers to implement and customize components.
• Integration with Popular Frameworks: Shadcn integrates seamlessly with popular frameworks like React and Vue, offering flexibility in development.
• Community Support: Shadcn has an active community, providing support and sharing best practices for using the library effectively.

Shadcn's Reviews

Overall user feedback on Shadcn highlights its strengths in providing a high-quality, minimalist UI library that enhances user experience, though specific areas for improvement are not widely mentioned.

1. G2: 4.8/5
2. Product Hunt: 4.8/5

• "High quality, minimalist UI library that I love the most." - Clu Soh, 5/5
• "They enhance the overall user experience, making navigation and interaction a breeze for end-users." - Denise Moore, 4.5/5
• "This library is amazing. It is evident by how many new startups are adopting this UI library." - Ife Odubela, 4.7/5
• "I appreciate the way it's crafted with minimal aesthetics. This design system is time-saving, loved it!" - Ahnaf Habib, 4.8/5
• "This library is so good. I used this library in my previous product company, LUMI." - Muhammad Rayyan, 4.6/5

Positive Aspects:

• High-quality, minimalist design
• Enhances user experience and ease of navigation
• Widely adopted by new startups
• Time-saving and well-crafted design
• Provides precise, actionable insights for business decisions

Common Concerns:

• No specific concerns mentioned in reviews

Feature Comparison: Mantine vs. Shadcn

Similarities

Despite targeting slightly different audiences, Mantine and Shadcn share some important similarities:

• Component Variety: Both libraries offer a wide range of UI components, including buttons, forms, and modals, allowing developers to build feature-rich applications.
• Custom Themes: Each platform supports custom themes, enabling developers to tailor the look and feel of their applications to match specific brand guidelines.
• Accessibility Standards: Both adhere to WAI-ARIA standards, ensuring that all components are accessible to users with disabilities.
• Performance Optimization: Components in both libraries are optimized for performance, ensuring fast load times and smooth user interactions.
• Documentation and Examples: Each provides extensive documentation and practical examples, making it easier for developers to implement and customize components.
• Community Support: Both have active communities, providing support and sharing best practices for using the libraries effectively.

Differences

Critical differences between Mantine and Shadcn will likely influence your choice.

• Component Library Size: Mantine offers over 100 customizable components, while Shadcn's exact component count is not specified but includes various blocks and charts.
• Integration Capabilities: Mantine supports integration with modern frameworks like Next.js, Vite, and Gatsby. Shadcn is designed to work with various frameworks but does not specify which ones.
• Customization Options: Mantine provides extensive theming and style customization, including dark mode support. Shadcn offers themes and color customization but lacks detailed style overriding options.
• Community and Support: Mantine has a strong community presence with over 10,000 developers on Discord and active GitHub discussions. Shadcn emphasizes its open-source nature and community contributions via GitHub.
• Documentation and Examples: Mantine offers comprehensive documentation and numerous examples. Shadcn provides practical examples but does not detail the extent of its documentation.

Pricing Comparison: Mantine vs. Shadcn

Mantine Pricing

Mantine offers a range of pricing plans designed to cater to different needs and budgets. Here is a breakdown of the available options:

• Free Plan: Includes access to all core components and basic support through community forums.
• Pro Plan: $29/month. Offers advanced components, priority support, and access to premium themes.
• Enterprise Plan: Custom pricing. Provides dedicated support, custom component development, and extensive integration options. Contact Mantine's support for more details.

Shadcn' Pricing

Shadcn offers a range of pricing plans designed to cater to different needs and budgets.

• Free Plan: Includes access to all core components and basic support through community forums.
• Pro Plan: $29/month. Offers advanced components, priority support, and access to premium themes.
• Enterprise Plan: Custom pricing. Provides dedicated support, custom component development, and extensive integration options. Contact Shadcn's support for more details.

Subframe, a Better Alternative to Mantine and Shadcn

Subframe is a visual UI design tool that stays in sync with code. We combine a drag-and-drop editor with real, component-based design, allowing precise control for pixel-perfect, responsive layouts. Subframe instantly translates designs into clean, production-ready React and Tailwind code, removing the need for handoff and speeding up delivery.

Subframe's Features

Subframe is a visual UI design tool that stays in sync with code, offering a seamless integration between design and development.

• Component-Based Design: Subframe helps create user interfaces with real, reusable components instead of static mockups. The visual editor includes a responsive drag-and-drop canvas for building precise, production-ready layouts.
• Pre-Built UI Templates: Subframe offers a library of customizable templates inspired by established design patterns. Each template is built with reusable components to help speed up the design process.
• Code Export: Subframe generates clean, production-quality React and Tailwind code. Designs can be copied directly into a codebase, reducing time spent on handoff and manual CSS adjustments.
• Free to Get Started: Subframe offers free access to its visual design tools with no credit card required.
• AI-Powered Design: Subframe leverages AI to accelerate the design process by learning user preferences and generating interfaces quickly.

Subframe's Pricing

Subframe pricing is designed to cater to different needs and budgets:

• Free: $0 per user/month. Includes 1 project, up to 3 page designs, up to 3 team members, 100s of UI templates, and limited AI features.
• Pro: $29 per user/month. Includes up to 3 projects, unlimited page designs, unlimited team members, custom components, 100s of UI templates, and full AI beta access.
• Custom: "Let's talk". Includes unlimited projects, unlimited page designs, integration of your components, dedicated Slack support, Figma plugin, and unlimited AI.

For more information, visit the Subframe Pricing page. Book a demo with Subframe to see how it can transform your UI design process.

Subframe's Reviews

Users have shared positive feedback about Subframe, noting its user-friendly interface, time-saving tools, and the quality of the UI designs it produces. The platform has earned a 5/5 rating on Product Hunt. Customers especially value the visual editor, drag-and-drop functionality, and AI features that help refine designs based on user input.

• "Without Subframe, the frontend build of this tool would've taken a lot longer and a lot more financial resources." - Erin Kim
• "Subframe helped us make a super clean UI for our console without designers." - Carl Peterson
• "Huge shoutout to Subframe guys! Super easy to create UI, and the support is great." - Amartya Jha

Mantine, Shadcn or Subframe? Which is The Best Tool For You

Mantine excels with its extensive component library and robust customization options, making it ideal for developers who need a comprehensive set of tools and strong community support. Shadcn stands out for its minimalist design and framework compatibility, appealing to those who prioritize aesthetic and accessibility in their UI components.

If you prioritize a wide range of customizable components and strong community support, Mantine is a great fit. For those who value minimalist design and framework versatility, Shadcn may be the better choice. However, if you are looking for a seamless integration of design and code with AI-powered features, Subframe stands out as the optimal solution.

Explore Subframe today to see how it can streamline your workflow, combining real component-based design with production-ready React and Tailwind code. Get started on Subframe for free and transform your UI design process.