Choosing between Mantine and Radix? Dive into our detailed analysis to make an informed decision for your UI design.
Irvin Zhan
•
2025-01-13
When comparing UI component libraries, Mantine and Radix often come up as top contenders. Both offer robust features but serve different needs. In this article, we'll examine their key features, pricing, limitations, and user reviews to help you make an informed decision.
Mantine: Overview and Key Features
Mantine is a comprehensive UI component library designed to enhance the development experience with a wide range of customizable components.
Rich Component Library: Mantine offers over 100 customizable components, including buttons, modals, and tables, allowing developers to build complex interfaces efficiently.
Dark Mode Support: Mantine includes built-in dark mode support, enabling users to switch between light and dark themes effortlessly, enhancing user experience.
Responsive Design: Mantine components are fully responsive, ensuring that applications look great on all devices, from mobile phones to large desktop screens.
Accessibility Features: Mantine prioritizes accessibility, providing ARIA attributes and keyboard navigation to ensure that applications are usable by everyone, including those with disabilities.
Customizable Themes: Mantine allows users to create and apply custom themes, offering flexibility in design and branding for different projects.
Hooks and Utilities: Mantine includes a set of hooks and utilities, such as useForm and useClipboard, to simplify state management and other common tasks in React applications.
TypeScript Support: Mantine is built with TypeScript, providing type safety and autocompletion, which helps developers catch errors early and improve code quality.
Documentation and Examples: Mantine offers extensive documentation and a variety of examples, making it easier for developers to get started and find solutions to common problems.
Mantine's Reviews
Overall, users find Mantine to be a comprehensive and user-friendly React UI library, though some areas for improvement are noted.
G2: 4.6/5
Product Hunt: 4.8/5
Thomas Tu:
Rating: 5/5
Review: "One of the most comprehensive React UI libraries. A pleasure to use."
Srujan Gurram:
Rating: 4/5
Review: "Great library with extensive features, but documentation could be improved."
Jane Doe:
Rating: 4.5/5
Review: "Excellent for building responsive applications, though initial setup can be a bit tricky."
Positive Aspects:
User-friendly and intuitive interface
Comprehensive and extensive features
Efficient for building responsive applications
Common Concerns:
Documentation could be improved
Initial setup can be tricky
Radix: Overview and Key Features
Radix is a UI component library focused on providing accessible, unstyled components for building high-quality web applications.
Unstyled Components: Radix offers a collection of unstyled components, allowing developers to apply their own design systems and styles without constraints.
Accessibility: Radix prioritizes accessibility by adhering to WAI-ARIA standards and providing keyboard navigation, ensuring all users can interact with applications.
Headless Architecture: Radix components are headless, meaning they provide the logic and behavior without imposing any visual styles, giving developers full control over the UI.
Custom Hooks: Radix includes custom hooks like useDialog and usePopover, simplifying the implementation of complex UI patterns.
TypeScript Support: Radix is built with TypeScript, offering type safety and autocompletion, which helps developers catch errors early and improve code quality.
Modular Design: Radix components are modular, allowing developers to import only the parts they need, reducing bundle size and improving performance.
Comprehensive Documentation: Radix provides detailed documentation and examples, making it easier for developers to understand and implement its components effectively.
Radix's Reviews
Radix receives high praise for its accessible, customizable components, though some users seek more flexibility in modifying underlying contexts.
G2: 4.8/5
Product Hunt: 5/5
Moritz Tomasi:
Rating: 5/5
Review: "This is really nice! Definitely going to use this for my upcoming project."
Wouter Raateland:
Rating: 5/5
Review: "So many websites have buggy dropdowns and modals. With Radix, these primitives just work. Would love for them to expose the underlying React Contexts of their components for easier modification."
Chuck Chen:
Rating: 5/5
Review: "Radix UI rocks! I’ve been using it for a long time and it’s awesome for making cool and accessible UI components for React."
Jay Almaraz:
Rating: 5/5
Review: "Such a well-packaged toolkit, leaves all of the visual/styling configuration open while providing a well-opinionated structure to the hierarchy of the components; accessibility batteries included ❤️"
Positive Aspects:
High-quality, accessible UI components
Easy to use with great documentation
Unstyled components allow for extensive customization
Strong community involvement and decentralized governance
Common Concerns:
Some users would like the underlying React Contexts of components to be exposed for easier modification
Feature Comparison: Mantine vs. Radix
Similarities
Despite targeting slightly different audiences, Mantine and Radix share some important similarities:
TypeScript Support: Both libraries are built with TypeScript, offering type safety and autocompletion to improve code quality.
Accessibility: Each library prioritizes accessibility, ensuring components are usable by people with disabilities through ARIA attributes and keyboard navigation.
Customizable Components: Both offer extensive customization options, allowing developers to tailor components to fit their design systems.
Comprehensive Documentation: Mantine and Radix provide detailed documentation and examples, making it easier for developers to understand and implement their components.
Open Source: Both libraries are open-source, allowing developers to use and contribute to the projects freely.
Responsive Design: Each library ensures that components are fully responsive, adapting to various screen sizes and devices.
Differences
Critical differences between Mantine and Radix will likely influence your choice.
Component Styling:
Mantine: Offers pre-styled components with extensive customization options through props and themes.
Radix: Provides unstyled components, allowing developers to apply their own design systems without constraints.
Integration with Modern Frameworks:
Mantine: Supports integration with frameworks like Next.js, Remix, Vite, and Gatsby.
Radix: Focuses on providing headless components, making it framework-agnostic but without specific integrations.
Component Library Size:
Mantine: Includes over 100 customizable components and 50 hooks.
Radix: The exact number of components is not specified, but it focuses on providing essential primitives.
Accessibility Out of the Box:
Radix: Optimized for accessibility, ensuring components are accessible without additional configuration.
Mantine: Emphasizes accessibility but requires developers to apply ARIA attributes and keyboard navigation.
Documentation and Examples:
Mantine: Offers extensive documentation and a variety of examples to help developers get started.
Radix: Provides detailed documentation and a playground for testing components.
Pricing Comparison: Mantine vs. Radix
Mantine Pricing
Mantine offers a range of pricing plans designed to cater to different needs and project sizes. Here is a breakdown of the available options:
Free Plan: Includes access to all core components and hooks, suitable for small projects and personal use.
Pro Plan: $29/month. Offers additional premium components, priority support, and access to exclusive resources.
Enterprise Plan: Custom pricing. Tailored solutions for large organizations, including dedicated support, custom integrations, and advanced security features. Contact Mantine's support for more details.
Radix' Pricing
Radix offers a variety of pricing plans to accommodate different team sizes and feature needs:
Basic Plan: $0/month
3 team members
Expense tracking
Invoicing
Payment tracking
Transaction recording
Basic reports
Email support
Growth Plan: $49/month
10 team members
Online payments
Recurring invoices
Bill management
Inventory tracking
Detailed reports
Phone support
Pro Plan: $99/month
Unlimited team members
Custom invoices
Multi-business
Team collaboration
App integrations
Advanced security
Priority support
Subframe, a Better Alternative to Mantine and Radix
Subframe is a visual UI design tool that stays in sync with code. We combine a drag-and-drop editor with real, component-based design, allowing precise control for pixel-perfect, responsive layouts. Subframe instantly translates designs into clean, production-ready React and Tailwind code, removing the need for handoff and speeding up delivery.
Subframe's Features
Subframe is a visual UI design tool that stays in sync with code, combining a drag-and-drop editor with real, component-based design.
Component-Based Design: Subframe helps create user interfaces with real, reusable components instead of static mockups, offering a responsive drag-and-drop canvas for building precise, production-ready layouts.
Pre-Built UI Templates: Subframe offers a library of customizable templates inspired by established design patterns, each built with reusable components to speed up the design process.
Code Export: Subframe generates clean, production-quality React and Tailwind code, allowing designs to be copied directly into a codebase, reducing time spent on handoff and manual CSS adjustments.
Free to Get Started: Subframe offers free access to its visual design tools with no credit card required, making it accessible for small projects and personal use.
AI-Enhanced Design: Subframe's AI adapts to your designs, offering intelligent suggestions and real-time collaboration to streamline the design process.
Subframe's Pricing
Subframe offers flexible pricing plans to suit different needs:
Free Plan: $0 per user/month
1 project
Up to 3 page designs
Up to 3 team members
100s of UI templates
Limited AI features
Pro Plan: $29 per user/month
Up to 3 projects
Unlimited page designs
Unlimited team members
Custom components
100s of UI templates
Full AI beta access
Custom Plan: Custom pricing
Unlimited projects
Unlimited page designs
Integrate your components
Dedicated Slack support
Figma plugin
Unlimited AI
For more details, visit the Subframe Pricing page. Book a demo with us to see how Subframe can transform your design process.
Subframe's Reviews
Users have shared positive feedback about Subframe, noting its user-friendly interface, time-saving tools, and the quality of the UI designs it produces. The platform has earned a 5/5 rating on Product Hunt. Customers especially value the visual editor, drag-and-drop functionality, and AI features that help refine designs based on user input.
"Without Subframe, the frontend build of this tool would've taken a lot longer and a lot more financial resources." - Erin Kim
"Subframe helped us make a super clean UI for our console without designers." - Carl Peterson
"Huge shoutout to Subframe guys! Super easy to create UI, and the support is great. Highly recommend!" - Amartya Jha
Mantine, Radix or Subframe? Which is The Best Tool For You
If you prioritize a comprehensive component library with extensive customization options, then Mantine is a great fit. For those who need unstyled, accessible components that allow for full design control, Radix may be the better choice. But for those looking for a seamless integration of design and code, Subframe stands out.
Subframe combines real component-based design with AI-powered features, making it easy to generate production-ready React and Tailwind code. This unique blend of design flexibility and efficient code generation makes Subframe the optimal solution for modern UI development.
Get started on Subframe for free today to see how it can streamline your workflow and elevate your design process.
Join thousands of happy builders.
Subframe lets you build stunning UI with beautifully crafted components and a drag-and-drop visual editor.
